In order to understand the complexity in Middle East, one has to be scientist, historian, anthropologist, geo-political startegist, cultural expert, economist and more....
The integral model pioneered by Plato, Ken Wilber, Graves, Don Beck and many others, offers an all comprehensive view of a cultural, national or organizational situations allowing us to have an awareness of a 'holonic' multi-dimensional perspective of the world.
Last week in New York, in collaboration with the Integral Salon NY and the SDi group, we gave a presentation on the integral map of the Middle East vs. a flatland map. That integral map included Life conditions in the conflict ridden countries, geo-political aspect as well as a 1st person perspective of each of the parties involved.
In the presentation we presented the Flow nessecary to design natural systems to allow vertical change, not just traditional negotiation processes and horizontal solutions. The map included Palestine, Israel, Hezbollah, Lebanon, Syria, Iran , US, EU and the UN and covered the following:
A- Life conditions (Internal & external):
Historic Times: Location & particular stage of emergence
Geographic Place (natural /man-made),
Human Problems: Priorities, needs, concerns, existential problems
Social Circumstances: socio-economic class. Educational level, opportunities and access...
B- Dynamics of Change: Open-Arrested-Closed. The 10 conditions for change
C- Design & Alignment : Matching Job to be done with value-systems, future visioning for the region , strategic thinking, long and short-term planning into a single stream-line flow.
and here's an example...
1. Hezbollah
Life Conditions: ( rural, religious, survival and dedication, no consumerism, strong loyalty to the family, tribe, and political leader, fearlessness (the strongest power in Lebanon) )
Historic Times: Shia'a faction in Lebanon was historically neglected and abused by its clan leaders and the Lebanese Leaders. They carry the victim archetype in their religious traditions since Ali the leader of Shia was persecuted and his sons were killed in Karbalaa (Ashoura celebration, flagellation rituals)
Geographic Place: Rural, agriculture, no access to amenities (electricity, shopping centers etc..) and social services
Human Problems: Neglected, mistreated, less than. Lack of respect and leadership in the country. Big families of 10 children and more. Poverty..
Social circumstances: lower class. No access to good education before Hezbollah's rise on the Lebanese scene and Iran's support. Day laborers. Multiple marriages. Tribal traditions not allowing for individuality.
1st person perspective: I am part of the New Order that brings respect to a humiliated Middle East. I am not a Sunni, I am not a Sunni jihadist. I have my Shia revolution brand of ‘Resistance' standing up to the Immoral West, our corrupt, oppressive Leaders and to Zionism that displaced Our Palestinian People and defeated the Muslims. When given the right opportunity I can compete with the best minds in the world, I am a human being. I respect my community, offer services to the disadvantaged, create opportunities for my people, in return I expect complete loyalty. I am a lawyer, dentist, teacher, PhD candidate, mother, father.....
The Transformational part of the process was the Experiential one that was an eye opener for all of us. We asked one of the participants to take on the role of the Palestinian 1st person, and another to be the Iranian etc...I could see the face of each 1st person participant change as he/she took on that role. They even felt alienated and that their voices dissapeared...reduced to their nationality, people feel limited, confined and misrepresented...
The whole experience from exterior/objective view of individuals and systems, to interior/subjective view of culture and 1st person, showed many other dimesions of the conflict in the Middle East...
Of course what we did was a very simplified process of how in real life application this should be done, but this gave a glimpse of potentiality and opportunities.